Loading verified data
Preparing the comparison experience…
The short answer
Marshall Middleton II wins this comparison. Choose it if a lower purchase price is your priority. Marshall Middleton II has the lower recorded reference price: $329.99 versus $399.95, a $69.96 difference.
JBL
A larger speaker for outdoor gatherings, with a shoulder strap, phone charging and ambient lighting. IP68 protection suits outdoor use; its 6.39 lb weight is the carrying tradeoff.
Bettr Score
66.1/100
Marshall
Built for long weekends, with 30+ hours of playtime, 360° sound and phone charging. Bass and treble controls let you adjust the sound; expect 3.97 lb to carry.
Bettr Score
66.5/100
| JBL Xtreme 5 | Specification | Marshall Middleton II |
|---|---|---|
$399.95 | Reference price | $329.99 ✓ Winner |
28 hours | Advertised battery life | 30 hours ✓ Winner |
6.39 lb | Weight | 3.97 lb ✓ Winner |
IP68 | Ingress protectionPersonal preference | IP67 |
5 ✓ Winner | Durability tier | 4 |
6.0 | Bluetooth versionPersonal preference | 5.3 |
Yes | Can charge another deviceTie | Yes |
Yes | USB audio inputNot enough data | Not stated / not applicable |
Yes | Auracast or compatible broadcast pairingTie | Yes |
No | Floats in waterNot enough data | Not stated / not applicable |
No | Speakerphone | Yes ✓ Winner |
The buying advice
The verified differences do not give JBL Xtreme 5 a clear advantage in this pair. Check its current offer and any requirements outside this comparison before choosing it.
Choose Marshall Middleton II if you want less weight in your bag. Marshall Middleton II weighs 3.97 lb versus 6.39 lb — 2.43 lb less to carry.
Marshall Middleton II weighs 3.97 lb versus 6.39 lb — 2.43 lb less to carry.
Marshall Middleton II weighs 3.97 lb versus 6.39 lb — 2.43 lb less to carry.
Marshall Middleton II has the lower recorded reference price: $329.99 versus $399.95, a $69.96 difference.
Marshall Middleton II supports speakerphone calls; the other speaker’s verified specification says it does not.
People's Pick
Loading voting options…
eBay — New
In stock · checked Oct 30, 2026
Price needs rechecking. Confirm at the retailer.
$229.99
Item + shipping · before tax
$229.99 + $0.00 shipping
We may earn a commission when you buy through links marked “Affiliate link.” This does not change your price or our scores. How we earn
eBay — New
In stock · checked Oct 30, 2026
Price needs rechecking. Confirm at the retailer.
$299.00
Item price · shipping unknown
We may earn a commission when you buy through links marked “Affiliate link.” This does not change your price or our scores. How we earn
Compare Portable Speakers
